KCintheFOXbox's Blog

Which was the bigger shocker on last night's American Idol?

Was it CARLY IN THE BOTTOM THREE?

or

AMANDA GOING HOME!

Even though I love Amanda's style -- I thought it was only a matter of time before she went, but who could have predicted that Carly Smithson would have been in the bottom three?  WOW!  I'm not the biggest fan of the Irish lass, but I certainly though she'd be there into the top 5.  From my stand point, I thought the style was ridiculous on her -- the rosettes on the salmon top clashed horribly with the arm sleeve of tattoos.  BUT the bigger thing that I think got her, was the Blackbird song choice explanation.  She spent time explaining to Simon how she was the bird with the broken wing because she's been trying to make it in the music industry.  I think people might NOT have voted for her based on that.

I voted a lot for Syesha because I thought she deserved to stay and was worried that her fanbase might not pick up the phone and vote. 

They also announced the mentors for this season.  Head over to my video blog (link below) for my full rundown/recap of the last American Idol episode -- and get the dirt on a TMZ rumour making the rounds!

K.C.'s Idol Wrap

See ya 'round the FOXbox!

K.C.